Why “Bad Direction” Isn’t Actually a Thing (From a Working Actor’s Perspective)
Let me say something that might ruffle a few feathers:
I don’t believe in bad direction.
Yes, I said it.
I’ve heard actors complain time and time again:
“The director just said ‘do it quicker’ or ‘be more sad’… that’s not helpful.”
But honestly?
As a working actress… that is exactly what I want.
Clear. Simple. Actionable.
On set, there is one truth that overrides everything else:
There is no time.
No time for an hour-long deep dive into your character’s childhood.
No time to unpack every emotional beat in a scene.
No time to philosophise.
What there is time for is getting the job done.
So when a director says:
“Say it quicker”
“More urgency”
“Make it happier”
That’s not “bad direction.”
That’s clear, usable direction.
It tells me exactly what adjustment to make, right now, in this take.
From the Studio Floor
Directing actors weekly in our Screen Acting Gym classes and working with countless performers in self-tapes, I see this firsthand.
Actors don’t struggle because direction is too simple.
They struggle because they overthink it.
They start translating:
“What does ‘more sad’ really mean?”
“What’s the deeper intention behind ‘quicker’?”
No.
Just do it.
Make it sadder.
Make it faster.
Commit fully and adjust.
The “Controversial” Bit… Line Reads
Alright, here’s where it might get spicy:
I don’t mind a line read.
There, I said it.
If a director needs something specific and I’m not quite landing it after a few takes… just tell me.
Show me.
Let’s move on.
It’s not an insult.
It’s not a reflection of my ability.
It’s part of the job.
Because again:
We are there to get the shot.
Time is money. The crew is waiting. The light is changing. The day is moving.
This isn’t rehearsal in a black box theatre.
This is a working set.
Yes, There’s a Time for Exploration
Now, let’s be clear — when there is time, exploration is magic.
Those moments where a director guides you with questions, where you discover something organically, where the performance evolves from within…
That’s gold.
But in my experience, after years on set:
That is the exception, not the rule.
Most directors are:
Thinking about the next setup
Adjusting the shot list
Editing the film in their head in real time
They don’t have the bandwidth to walk you through every emotional beat.
And that’s okay.
Reframing “Bad Direction”
So next time you hear:
“Do it more happy.”
Don’t roll your eyes.
Don’t overanalyse.
Don’t take it personally.
Do the job.
Make it brighter.
Lift the energy.
Commit 100%.
Because great actors aren’t the ones who need perfect, poetic direction.
They’re the ones who can translate simple direction into compelling performance instantly.
Final Thought
“Bad direction” isn’t the problem.
Resistance to direction is.
So let’s drop the ego, stop overcomplicating, and remember what we’re there to do:
Deliver. Adjust. Deliver again.
And yes—
Make it bloody happy when they ask for it.
Sending you a big hug,
Natalia
Owning It Acting Studio
If you enjoyed my blog and it resonated with you, I’d be truly grateful if you shared it on your social media so it might support other actors as well. My goal is to create a safe, encouraging space where actors can feel seen and supported.
